Corrigan given leave to challenge Smithwick Tribunal findings

Retired Garda Owen Corrigan

Retired Garda Owen Corrigan

The High Court yesterday granted permission to a retired Dundalk detective to challenge a finding by the Smithwick Tribunal that he gave information to the IRA about a man it later murdered.

Owen Corrigan totally rejects the “completely false and grossly damaging” findings that he told a senior IRA operative the late Tom Oliver, from Riverstown on the Cooley Peninsula, was a Garda informant shortly before Mr Oliver was abducted and murdered, his counsel, Jim O’Callaghan SC, said.

Mr Justice Michael Moriarty said yesterday, after “careful consideration”, he would grant leave to Mr Corrigan to bring his judicial review challenge aimed at quashing and removing certain findings relating to him in the tribunal report.

The tribunal was set up to inquire into the killing by the IRA in 1989 of senior RUC officers Chief Supt Harry Breen and Supt Robert Buchanan.

The tribunal made no finding Mr Corrigan was involved in collusion with the IRA in respect of the deaths of those officers.

In his action, Mr Corrigan claims he was denied fair procedures as he was not given advance notice that any finding in respect of Mr Oliver’s death could be made against him.

In making that finding, the tribunal acted outside its terms of reference, which was to investigate the allegation of collusion in the death of the two RUC officers, he claims.

Mr Justice Moriarty granted leave to challenge that finding but refused leave to challenge another finding that Mr Corrigan had not co-operated with the tribunal over providing details of his bank account.

In his final report, Judge Peter Smithwick said he accepted evidence from Kevin Fulton, who said he worked for the British military’s intelligence unit in Northern Ireland.

Mr Fulton had told the tribunal Mr Corrigan had provided information that Mr Oliver was an informant to Mooch Blair, a senior member of the IRA, in the car park of a Dundalk pub in 1991 as a result of which, Mr Fulton said, Mr Oliver was murdered by the IRA.

In his evidence to the tribunal, Mr Corrigan denied Mr Fulton’s claims.

Source: The Irish Times

Corrigan launches legal challenge to Smithwick Tribunal findings

Owen Corrigan

Owen Corrigan

A retired Dundalk garda has begun a legal challenge against findings by the Smithwick Tribunal that he gave information to the IRA about a man it subsequently murdered.

The High Court heard yesterday that Owen Corrigan totally rejected findings made by former District Court President Peter Smithwick.

Judge Smithwick found that the retired detective told a senior IRA operative the late Tom Oliver, from Riverstown, was a garda informant shortly before Mr Oliver was abducted and murdered on July 19th 1991.

Mr Corrigan wants the court to quash and remove certain findings about him contained in the judge’s report concerning the killing of senior RUC officers Chief Superintendent Harry Breen and Superintendent Robert Buchanan by the IRA in March 1989.

The Smithwick Tribunal was set up to investigate claims that a member of An Garda Síochána colluded with the Provisional IRA in the murders.

Last December, the tribunal found that unnamed members of the gardaí had colluded with the IRA in respect of the RUC men’s deaths.

The tribunal made no finding that Mr Corrigan, who retired in 1992, was involved in this collusion.

The application to bring the challenge was made before Mr Justice Michael Moriarty.

The judge said he would consider the matter and give his ruling whether to grant leave today.

Smithwick reserves judgement on Corrigan costs

Retired Garda Owen Corrigan

Retired Garda Owen Corrigan

Mr Justice Peter Swithwick has reserved judgment on the application by retired garda Owen Corrigan for his costs arising from the tribunal.

The former detective sergeant was one of three former gardaí who were investigated by the tribunal to see if they colluded with the IRA in the murder of two senior RUC officers.

Chief Supt Harry Breen and Supt Bob Buchanan died after they left a meeting at Dundalk Garda Station in March 1989.

The tribunal found that there was collusion, but said it was impossible to identify who had leaked the information about the meeting to the IRA.

Mr Justice Smithwick concluded that Mr Corrigan’s evidence was evasive, inconsistent and not credible.

He also concluded that Mr Corrigan had had inappropriate dealings with the IRA.

The decision comes just days after a group of retired senior gardai submitted a report to government criticising the findings of the Smithwick Tribunal in an unprecedented challenge to a State tribunal by former members of the force.

The senior officers are questioning the tribunal’s conclusion that gardai colluded in the IRA murder of the two RUC officers in South Armagh in 1989.

Judge Peter Smithwick concluded that on the “balance of probabilities” there was garda collusion in their deaths – but he was unable to identify possible culprits.

The retired gardai are understood to be deeply unhappy with the judge’s findings. They commissioned a lengthy critique of his report and submitted it to the Government this weekend.

Source: RTÉ News.

Corrigan rejects findings of Smithwick Tribunal

Owen Corrigan

Owen Corrigan

One of the three former garda sergeants quizzed by the Smithwick Tribunal has rejected its findings that he had inappropriate contact with the IRA.

Former Detective Sergeant Owen Corrigan said the tribunal findings had placed a cloud of suspicion over all former Dundalk-based gardai.

In a statement he said he welcomed the fact Judge Smithwick had reached no finding of collusion against him regarding the murder of two RUC officers, Chief Supt Harry Breen and Supt. Bob Buchanan.

“I do not accept, however, his finding that I had an inappropriate relationship with the Provisional IRA.

“All my dealings with PIRA were for the purpose of gathering information and/or intelligence to support the gardai in defending the State and its people during The Troubles,” Mr Corrigan said in the statement issued via his solicitors, Lawlor Partners.

Judge Smithwick had criticised Mr Corrigan’s evidence at the Tribunal describing it as evasive.

However, while he ruled the former detective garda did have inappropriate dealings with the IRA, the evidence was not sufficient to draw a conclusion that he had colluded with the IRA in the murders.

In his statement today, Mr Corrigan said that for 32 years he served in the border area during a time of unprecedented troubles.

“I served my force and my country to the best of my ability during a time when the campaign of violence by the Provisional IRA was at its height.

“I suffered considerable violence and intimidation with ‘wanted for treason’ posters of me erected by republicans in Dundalk,” he said.

He also reiterated that he was severely beaten by members of the IRA although Judge Smithwick ruled that happened because of a commercial deal with PIRA after he had retired from the force.

In addition, Mr Corrigan went on to say that he did not believe any member of the gardai colluded in the murder of the two RUC officers.

“Judge Smithwick’s finding has now placed a cloud of suspicion over all former members of Dundalk Garda Station in circumstances where there is no direct evidence,” he said.

Source: RTÉ News

Smithwick Tribunal to end today

Ch Supt Harry Breen and Supt Bob Buchanan were murdered by the IRA in March 1989

Ch Supt Harry Breen and Supt Bob Buchanan were murdered by the IRA in March 1989

A public inquiry into the murders of the two most senior Royal Ulster Constabulary officers killed during the Troubles is expected to end today.

The Smithwick Tribunal was set up to investigate claims that local Gardaí colluded in the deaths of RUC Chief Supt Harry Breen and Supt Bob Buchanan.

They were shot dead an an IRA ambush while returning from a meeting in Dundalk Garda Station.

The Dublin-based tribunal is due to hear closing statements today.

Over 200 witnesses have testified since the tribunal was established in 2005, including former IRA members and spies in the British security services.

Many allegations were made, some centring on former garda sergeant Owen Corrigan.

He denied collaborating with the IRA, despite one RUC intelligence document that said he passed on information.

Suspicions have also fallen on two other Dundalk gardai; Leo Colton and Finbarr Hickey.

They too deny leaking information to the IRA.

In a statement to the inquiry, the IRA said the killings were the result of a lengthy surveillance operation and that they had no help from any garda officer.

While one British intelligence document suggested there were several Dundalk gardai up to and over the rank of sergeant leaking to the IRA, another British intelligence document said none of the three mentioned in the tribunal helped the IRA.

The inquiry also heard evidence of the PSNI not passing on recent intelligence on the murders to gardai.

So, the chairman, retired judge Peter Smithwick, will have a difficult task in reaching a definite conclusion with a verdict expected in October.

Former Dundalk Garda claims British forces tried to frame him of murder

smithwick-tribunal-deadline-310x415

British security services tried to frame a Garda sergeant over the murder of two senior police officers from the North to distract attention from their own collusion, an inquiry has heard.

Retired Sergeant Owen Corrigan said claims he passed on sensitive information to the IRA were a tactic by the British to switch the spotlight from their backing of loyalist paramilitaries.

Any other evidence against him in the long-running Smithwick Tribunal was down to gossip among police officers who had never met him, he said.

“Policemen are gossips, by and large,” he told the inquiry.

Mr Corrigan is the last witness to appear before the tribunal, which is investigating claims that some gardai colluded with the IRA gang that shot two Royal Ulster Constabulary officers in 1989.

Chief Superintendent Harry Breen and Superintendent Bob Buchanan died in an ambush in south Armagh shortly after they left a meeting at Dundalk Garda station.

Mr Corrigan, based at Dundalk Garda station at the time, told the inquiry the only evidence against him was a statement by a British army agent Kevin Fulton, also known as Peter Keeley.

The claims were made to strengthen allegations of a link between Irish authorities and the IRA in the wake of substantiated allegations of British security service collusion with loyalist paramilitaries, the tribunal heard.

“That is it in a nutshell,” said Mr Corrigan.

The former detective said Mr Fulton continued to be paid by the British security services while in prison serving a two-and-a-half-year sentence for armed robbery.

The allegations that Mr Corrigan was involved in collusion were the most serious ever made during a tribunal in the history of the Irish State and the most serious ever levelled against any member of the Garda, he said.

Mr Corrigan said he was not in charge of border security at the time of the killings, but had always opposed RUC officers coming to Dundalk Garda station, for their own safety.

The town was a hive of subversives, coming in and out of the station with documents to gather intelligence, he said.

But he said Mr Buchanan was a “God-fearing, good living” man who thought by divine intervention he would be saved from any injury during his work.

The Tribunal heard Mr Fulton made a statement in September 2003 that he was in a house on the day of the murders and a man told him that Mr Corrigan was involved.

His barrister Jim O’Callaghan said it “suited the intentions” of the British security services to link Mr Corrigan to the double killings.

The former detective said he was effectively in charge of border security up until the Anglo-Irish Agreement in 1985, and was the conduit through which all intelligence flowed.

“My name was on everyone’s lips,” he said.

Anyone who gave evidence against him – which he said was deeply offensive and insulting – would have heard of his name but had never met him, he told the hearing.

Whereas those who spoke out for him, including three Garda commissioners and a number of former RUC officers, knew him, he said.

Denying suggestions that he had made up story about being kidnapped and badly beaten by the IRA in 1995, he said evidence that he was nearly killed and never fully recovered was very accurate.

“I was a victim of my expertise and because I had built up an extensive, elaborate network of informants,” he said.

“I was the conduit through which all this information flowed and they knew it.”

Mr Corrigan said he made no claim for compensation and although he told colleagues what the IRA wanted from him, he did not make an official statement because he was concerned for the safety of his wife and family.

He also rejected claims he was being deceitful about his medical condition, when he went on sick leave from the force for nervous disability caused by stress of his work.

His condition was fully documented and overseen by the Garda surgeon.

Mr Corrigan said no-one can understand now the stress of policing Dundalk during the 1970s and 1980s.

“It wasn’t called El Paso for nothing,” he said.

Mr Corrigan also told the inquiry he resented insinuations about his personal finances, and that no-one ever put it to him directly whether he got money from the IRA, which he denied.

Outlining his property portfolio, he said built a house in Rathmullan, near Drogheda in 1968, for £1,500, with a loan for £2,000 from the local authority.

In 1983 he bought a property called Oakdene for £19,000, with a loan from the Ulster Bank for £12,000 along with a cash deposit, and then bought another property in 1976 with a loan from Bank of Ireland.

In 1988 he said he used a loan to purchase a property in Lawrence Street, Drogheda for £42,000 and when he retired in 1991, he bought a pub with a loan, along with a gratuity he received on leaving the force and the proceeds of selling the house at Rathmullan.

Source: TCH Media